The horticulture industry often discusses a shortage of experienced growers, the difficulty of succession planning and the need to recruit college graduates into production. Jeff Neese, a Biological Solutions Advisor for BioWorks in the Great Lakes region, argues that the conversation starts too late. Before asking where the next generation of growers will come from, he writes, the industry should ask where young people are supposed to discover horticulture.
Neese’s own experience began at Warren Central High School in Indianapolis. Walking into the school greenhouse during an Indiana winter, he found warmth, humidity and green plants instead of the cold, gray landscape outside. That doorway shaped the rest of his life. Vocational horticulture gave him a chance to see the work as a possible career, not merely a subject or a spring fundraiser.
Two teachers were central. Phil Pitts brought the perspective of a grower and landscape designer and set high expectations for what students should know. Pam Greene taught floriculture and introduced students more directly to a part of the industry that became important in Neese’s professional life. Together, they gave students something he worries too few young people have today: the opportunity to experience horticulture before being asked to decide what to do with their lives.
The program was not about memorizing plant names or filling out worksheets. Students were expected to understand plants and learn to grow them well. Pitts understood that horticulture does not follow a school schedule. Plants still need water on weekends. Insects and diseases do not wait until Monday morning. Crops respond to light, temperature, water and nutrition whether school is in session or not. Between Pitts’s expectations and Greene’s floriculture instruction, Neese began to see himself in the work.
After high school, he chose horticulture rather than college. He does not reject university education. The industry needs university-trained horticulturists, plant scientists, breeders, researchers and growers. But college was not his path, and vocational horticulture gave him enough knowledge, experience and confidence to know he wanted to build a career in the field. More than 40 years later, he is still doing it.
That history leads to a workforce argument. A 15- or 16-year-old is not likely to wake up one morning and decide greenhouse production sounds like a fascinating career. Someone has to show them. High-school vocational horticulture can be important to the industry’s future, but a greenhouse behind a school is not enough by itself. A greenhouse is a living laboratory, and operating one requires knowledge, commitment and time.
Agriculture teachers may be responsible for broad subjects. Expecting every one of them to also be an accomplished grower, crop scheduler, irrigation specialist, diagnostician, integrated pest management practitioner and environmental-control expert is not realistic. Nor should they be expected to develop all those skills alone. Neese argues that commercial growers should become active partners in helping schools develop them rather than waiting for schools to produce qualified employees.
He proposes that commercial operations essentially adopt local school greenhouses without taking over the teacher’s role or curriculum. They could serve as a technical resource: help build an achievable crop plan, set realistic standards for irrigation, fertility, pH, EC, temperature and timing, and walk the greenhouse with students to teach scouting, sticky-card use, root examination and nutritional diagnosis. Most important, they could show how growers think through problems and make decisions, help teachers use existing equipment and be a knowledgeable contact when something goes wrong.
The industry holds much practical growing knowledge, but most of it stays inside commercial greenhouse walls. If the industry is serious about its future workforce, some of that knowledge needs to reach the classroom. Not every instructor needs to be another Phil Pitts or Pam Greene. Teachers need enough industry expertise, encouragement and support for students to experience horticulture meaningfully.
Summer internships matter but are not enough by themselves. For most high-school students, summer is the only extended period of full-time work, and it can provide a narrow view of greenhouse production. Depending on the operation, much of spring’s diversity may be gone. It is hot and humid, and inexperienced seasonal employees can end up doing whatever job nobody else wants: sticking poinsettias, spacing crops, moving plants or cleaning houses. Those jobs are part of commercial horticulture, but if that is all a teenager experiences, the industry should not be surprised if greenhouse horticulture does not look exciting. The student has experienced labor, not necessarily management.
To understand growing, students need to see how production changes through the year: fall crops and shortening days, winter’s lower light and humidity, spring propagation and peak production, and summer’s heat, irrigation and preparation for the next cycle. Different crops, problems and decisions appear at every stage. An eight-week summer internship gives one snapshot. Learning horticulture requires seeing the whole movie.
Neese therefore argues that school and commercial greenhouses should function as extensions of one another. If a grower understands what students learn in class, the internship becomes the next chapter of their education rather than an unrelated summer job. Students who have studied pH and EC can see commercial monitoring; those who have learned scouting and IPM can join a crop walk; those who have studied irrigation and fertility can see injectors, water systems and fertilizer programs.
That relationship also creates a recruiting path. A student might meet a company as a sophomore taking horticulture classes. As a junior, the student might visit the greenhouse, work with a grower or spend the summer with the team. During senior year, the student can continue in the school greenhouse while maintaining the relationship. At graduation, the path into a horticulture career should already be visible.
Neese writes that some of the most rewarding growers he has worked with are people he helped grow. They learned the crops and the operation from the ground up, took on greater responsibility and gained confidence because someone invested time to teach them. That is more than recruiting. It is developing a horticulturist before young people leave high school.
College may be right for many students, and Neese says the industry should encourage it. But for those who cannot or do not want to attend, or who, like him, want to start, there should be another respected path. A talented 18-year-old with vocational horticulture, commercial exposure and mentorship is not unskilled labor but a young horticulturist at the start of a career. Give them responsibility, teaching and a clear view of where the career can lead.
Schools cannot solve the industry’s workforce challenges alone, and growers cannot solve vocational education alone. Neese sees opportunity between those worlds. Instead of only attending career fairs and posting jobs, growers can find the local agricultural education or horticulture program, meet the teacher, walk the school greenhouse and ask what is needed. Offer knowledge, not just old equipment and leftover plants.
Invite students into the operation in February as well as June. Let them scout, test EC, look at roots, see good and problem crops, make mistakes, diagnose problems and understand the decisions behind a quality crop. When they work in summer, do not just give them the job nobody else wants. Give them a reason to want the grower’s job someday.
Somewhere today another teenager is walking into a greenhouse for the first time and could become an exceptional grower, IPM specialist, propagator, production manager or owner. Phil Pitts and Pam Greene opened that door for Neese and changed his life. Horticulture was not a fallback if college did not work out; it was the opportunity. More than four decades later, part of what they taught him still walks into every greenhouse with him.
Neese suggests the industry stop waiting for someone else to produce its next generation. The future may already be in a high-school classroom.
